By Anthony Santiago - Editor-in-Chief

January 11, 2023
How Do I Determine the Value of a Trade In

If you're like many other car owners and me, you've probably found yourself trying to figure out the value of a trade-in. Getting the best price possible is important, but it can take time to determine what's fair and what isn't.

Well, I'm here to help! In this article, I'll provide expert insights and advice on properly assessing the value of a trade-in so that you can get the most out of your deal and not get ripped off.

Understanding the TRUE Value of a Trade-In Price

If you decide to trade in a car when buying a new one, it is crucial to know the vehicle's value before you go to the dealer.

When considering a trade-in, one of the most important questions is, "what is my vehicle worth?" When it comes to assessing value, you want to ensure you get an accurate estimate from a reliable source.

While no estimate is 100% accurate, there are ways to ensure you get the fairest value possible.

TIP: There is no such thing as perfect condition on a used car since there will be wear and tear. You can use tools to determine the actual condition of your trade-in. 

Many factors contribute to its worth that you should know. By understanding these factors and researching, you can gain a better and more accurate value for your vehicle. As a result, you can use it as a bargaining tool when negotiating with dealers.

Step 1: Researching the Value of Your Trade-In

The first step in determining your trade-in's value is to comparable research vehicles available or for sale in your local market - also known as "comps." This will give you a better idea of what someone is likely willing to pay for your used car.

Knowing the correct value of your trade-in vehicle also prevents salespeople from taking advantage of you.

You can begin by researching similar makes and models through websites such as Kelley Blue Book and Edmunds. You can also check how many similar used cars are listed for sale in nearby areas to get an idea of what people are being offered for their vehicles in current times.

Look at the listings that have sold. You can quickly gauge what's available in the market around you.

You can also dig a little deeper online. Several sources are available for this market research, such as Kelley Blue Book (KBB), NADA, Edmundsor your local newspaper's classified ads section. Knowing these prices will help you accurately assess what yours is worth in today's market conditions.

Step 2: Be Honest to Yourself about the Condition

Another key factor affecting the trade-in value is condition; cars with clean titles and those that have been properly maintained have higher values than ones with significant blemishes or damage from rust or accidents.

Dents and rust can decrease the price by hundreds, if not thousands, of dollars, so be mindful of the car's exterior.

TIP: Touchup paint and a detail can do wonders in improving the appearance of a vehicle.

A complete service history log book, maintenance history, or a dealer-only service can command a higher price. 

It is also beneficial to have documentation on any repairs, maintenance history, or custom work done throughout its life. This will provide a better indication of quality from which its current value can be determined.

Most dealerships offer free inspections before making any purchase agreement to get a quick assessment. Even if they disagree on the same sales price number, they can provide insight into its condition before heading into negotiations. However, take this with a grain of salt. You should already have done your homework by using online tools.

If you have a family friend or a trusted, qualified mechanic, ask them to help to assess its condition. While it might be difficult to recoup any recent maintenance costs, document any maintenance costs or repairs that have been completed recently. This can help increase its value when negotiating with prospective buyers or dealerships.

For example, if you recently had the brakes serviced with new rotors and pads, this can help justify the higher asking price or trade-in. But the market will dictate what buyers are willing to pay.

Step 3: Where Are You Trading In


Regarding trade-ins, they make it easy for you to get rid of your old vehicle and move into a new one. Again, do you are your homework. Read reviews about the dealership you're considering purchasing your next vehicle from. This can provide helpful insight into their practices, so you can ensure they're reliable and honest when offering a trade-in value for your car.

Remember that what somebody else may offer your car does not necessarily reflect its current value.

Option to Sell to a Private Party

When selling your vehicle, you can often make more money when dealing directly with a private buyer rather than trading it in at a dealership. That's because dealerships need to make a profit by reselling the car and potentially making repairs - meaning they will rarely pay as much for trade-ins compared to what an individual is willing to offer.

The private party value is typically much higher than the trade-in value that a dealership would offer.

When you sell directly to an individual, you gain more power over the selling process and can bargain with them in person instead of taking whatever price a dealership offers. It's also good to share the original purchase price with the potential buyer as an incentive for the excellent asking price as a comparison.

An additional perk of selling to a private buyer is that the process can be more informal and flexible than trading in your car at a dealership.

Step 4: Factors that Affect the Value of Your Trade-In

When you are looking to trade in a vehicle, understanding the factors that affect the value of your car will help you get the highest possible return. Age, condition, mileage, and market value all impact your car's worth and should be considered when estimating its trade-in value.

I'll review the four important factors that will impact your trade-in.

  • Age: The age of a vehicle has an impact on its trade-in value. Newer cars are often more desirable than older ones and can typically command a higher price in exchange for their freshness and reliability. The time of sale also impacts the age, especially after New Year's Eve with the new year.

  • Exterior Condition: As mentioned already, your vehicle's condition significantly influences how much it will be valued during a trade-in, so take care to ensure that your car looks presentable when you go to sell it. Interior wear, exterior dents, or damaged paint can all decrease the overall worth of your vehicle after inspection from a dealer or private party buyer. Take it for a quick wash before the dealership inspect it.

  • Mechanical Issues: A running and driving vehicle will command a higher trade-in value. If your car has rough idle or smoke from the exhaust, it can greatly hamper and decrease the trade-in value significantly. 

  • Mileage: The mileage of a given vehicle plays into its overall valuation because it usually corresponds to years of use and wear and tear. Lower mileage cars tend to hold a higher value than vehicles with higher levels since they represent less time spent behind the wheel.

  • Market Value: Before trading in, research the current market of the available models for sale – both new and used – to get an accurate reading on what someone may expect as far as pricing goes upon trading it in later on down the line.

Step 5: Easy Ways to Improve Your Vehicle's Condition

Improving the physical condition is a great way to increase your vehicle's worth.

  1. Detail Exterior by Washing and Waxing: Regularly washing and waxing your car can improve its appearance and help protect the paint for long-term maintenance. Keeping your vehicle clean is one of the least complicated yet most efficient ways to maintain a like-new look!
  2. Detail the interior: A thorough interior cleaning of your car, from the floor mats to the dashboard and every seat in between, can help erase dirt stains and revive its appearance like it's brand new. It can also help get rid of the smoke smell. A good tip is to remove all personal items from the cabin and trunk for a clean look.
  3. Touchup Paint Dents and Scratches: The easiest and most efficient way to fix minor marks or scratches is by using a touchup paint pen, or if the damage is more extensive, you can opt for professional paintless dent repair (PDR).
  4. Clean All the Windows: By cleaning your car windows thoroughly and adding a coat of polish, you'll not only see them shine but boost the appearance of your entire vehicle. Enjoying clean and clear windows while driving can make all the difference in experience.
  5. Refurbish Worn-out Parts: Refinish your vehicle by refinishing plastic bumper pieces, mirrors, and trim. It's easy to make sure your car looks as good as new.
  6. Check the Wheels and Tires: Tire shine is a great way to revitalize your tires and make them look brand-new. With just one application, you can immediately bring back the luster and shine of your tires. However, any tire tread at 2/32 will need to be replaced.

Negotiating the Value of Your Trade-In

I have already covered the different tools you can use to help determine the trade-in value of your vehicle. Please note that your geographic location can also impact the trade-in value. 

Check out this exciting article from iSeeCars, on vehicle trends and the average cost of a car.

Whenever I discuss with the dealership, I first ensure they have the car I want to purchase. We should have already settled on the Out-the-Door (OTD) price or agreed-upon price on the vehicle. The dealership might be tempted to offer a higher value of your trade-in but also have a higher OTD price to offset that.

Remember to focus on the OTD price and that the trade-in value is more than an outstanding loan amount. Trade-ins are good for buyers with less than stellar credit as it helps decrease the auto loan amount.

In my experience, the dealership did increase the trade-in value by $1000 to help close the deal, so your dealership might do the same.

Different negotiating tactics can also help bring up the estimated final sale price, such as considering both cash and financing options offered by the dealership or using up any special offers they're running that week. Ultimately getting the most competitive deal requires being knowledgeable and prepared before going into negotiations with the dealership.

Finalizing the Trade-In Value

When assessing the worth of a vehicle up for trade-in, car appraisers typically consider several different factors, such as:

  1. The make, model, and year of the car: When calculating a vehicle's trade-in value, an appraiser will take into account the make, model, and year of it. This can play a significant role in its overall worth.

  2. The vehicle's condition level: The vehicle appraiser will evaluate the car's appearance, inner cabin state, and mechanical specs. This may include scrutinizing evidence of dents or scratches on its exterior, rust, and wear and tear to seats and flooring. Any future repair costs or reconditioning will impact the final trade-in value.

  3. The vehicle's mileage: The number of miles on a car can drastically influence its worth and will be carefully considered by appraisers when deciding the matter for trade-in.

  4. The vehicle's history: The car's past, including any accidents or repairs that have been made, will also be taken into consideration. They will also check if the inspection and registration are up to date.

  5. The vehicle's market demand: The price of a given vehicle can also be determined by the total current market values and demand for that particular make and model, as well as the number of comparable vehicles in nearby locations.

Maximizing the Value of Your Trade-In

When trading in your car, doing your research is essential to ensure you get the most money for your vehicle. It's important to know the fair market value of your car, as well as its trade-in value.

Knowing the value of your car will help you negotiate with dealers and other buyers to maximize the value of your trade-in.

  • Be sure to consider any extras or features that could add additional value to the car.

  • Cleaning and servicing the vehicle ahead of time can also add some desired improvements that may influence a buyer's decision on how much they offer in returns.

  • Exploring any available incentives offered by dealers for trading in a qualifying vehicle and keeping up with current pricing trends can help you better understand what kind of deal you should expect from potential buyers.

  • Staying informed will give you the knowledge and assurance to make more sound automotive decisions when maximizing your trade-in value.

Final Thoughts

Once you've weighed the pros and cons and decided to trade in your car, arriving at an accurate value is extremely important. Doing so may require some legwork on your end, but with the proper knowledge and resources, you can be sure that you are getting the best possible deal.

Remember to be thorough in your research and comparisons, as this will help ensure you get the most out of your trade-in.

More Articles Worth Checking Out:

Are you looking to know how to sell your car to Carvana? Carvana can make a fair offer to your car, truck,

Read More

Anthony Santiago - Editor-in-Chief

About the author

I am a passionate car enthusiast who likes to help people save money and avoid headaches when it comes to cars. I believe that everyone can find the right car at the right price. I share my tips and experience so you can learn quickly and maximize your next SUV, truck or car purchase.

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Get Your Free Guide:
Top 3 Rules to Buying a Car